Home › Island News › Local News
End of road, it’s the beginning for other candidates Tuesday
STORY TOOLS
RELATED STORIES
Related Links
- Election '08: Get complete coverage of the Marco Island City Council election
- Get the latest local and national election news in our special Election 2008 section.
More Local News
- Alternative revenue sources may be answer to Marco's property tax shortfall
- Vacation for procreation returns to Marco Island
- Marco's Code Board gives stiff fines for repeat offenders
Share and Enjoy [?]
Tuesday marks the end of the road for the 16 people running for Marco Island and Naples city councils.
Some will take a seat on their respective councils, while others will spend the next four years trying to make a difference from the other side of the council dais.
A combined eight seats — four on Marco Island, and four, including the mayor’s seat, in Naples — are up for election Tuesday. After months of campaigning, candidates will learn their fates when the polls close at 7 p.m.
Polls open at 7 a.m. for votes in the city contests, a property tax amendment and presidential preference races for Democrats and Republicans.
Marco Island candidates are split between pro- and anti-sewers. Pro-sewer candidates are Councilman Bill Trotter, Jerry Gibson, Frank Recker and Wayne Waldack; anti-sewer candidates are Joe Batte, Andrew Guidry, Roger Hall and Butch Neylon.
Representatives for both sides of the sewer debate said Monday they were optimistic about their chances.
“I feel our efforts in making our candidates’ names household names will pay off,” said Godfrey Davies, an anti-sewer strategist.
John Arceri, a pro-sewer strategist and former Marco Island councilman, said he hoped tonight’s results will put an end to the divisiveness caused by the sewers.
“Everyone I’m talking to says they’re going to support what the results are,” he said. “There’s a real feeling of reconciliation going on right now.”
Candidates for Naples City Council are Dorothy Hirsch, Teresa Heitmann, Gloria Kovacs, Councilman Johnny Nocera, Councilman John Sorey and Margaret “Dee” Sulick. Mayoral candidates are Mayor Bill Barnett and Henry Kennedy.
Both Marco Island and Naples City Council elections are nonpartisan, and council members represent the whole community, not a specific district.
Dave Carpenter, the qualifying officer at the Collier County Supervisor of Elections, said his office is expecting high turnout in both cities.
“As we move east in Collier County, the turnout drops off,” he said Monday. “There’s usually higher turnout in coastal areas.”
Carpenter said he wouldn’t be surprised if more than 60 percent of Naples registered voters came out to vote.
Turnout in the 2004 Naples City Council election was about 54 percent, Carpenter said. The increased turnout, he said, could be because of the presidential primary.
Turnout is expected to be higher on Marco Island, Carpenter said, where up to 70 percent of the island’s 12,361 registered voters — about 8,652 people — could be coming out to vote.
“With the intensity of the election, I can see us having a very high turnout,” Carpenter said.
The largest turnout in Marco Island’s history was in 1997, when the city’s incorporation was on the ballot. About 71 percent of registered voters turned out, compared to the 67 percent of registered voters who came out to vote for the City Council that same year.
Since then, turnout on Marco Island has held steady at around 50 percent.
In both Naples and on Marco Island, voters came out in droves to participate in early voting. About 4,719 people voted at Marco Island’s public library, while another 2,421 people voted at Naples City Hall during the early voting period.
Those numbers don’t necessarily reflect the number of people who voted in City Council elections in either city, since any county resident could vote at any of the early voting polling places.
But City Council elections aren’t the only thing voters will have to cast their ballot for Tuesday.
Collier County residents also will be asked to vote on a constitutional amendment and cast their vote in the presidential preference primary.
The elements of the tax-reform proposal include a $25,000 increase in the homestead exemption; portability that allows people to take all or a portion of their Save Our Homes tax protection when they move; a 10 percent cap on property value assessment increases for non-homestead properties; and a break for business taxes.
Collier County agencies could lose more than $20 million if voters approve the amendment.
Carpenter said voters need to make sure they know where their polling place is, or their vote won’t be counted.
“Under Florida law they must vote in the proper precinct for their vote to be tabulated,” Carpenter said.
“If someone goes to the wrong polling place, the clerk will look them up in our system and direct them to the proper polling place.”

Comments
This site does not necessarily agree with comments posted below — responsibility lies with the relevant reader alone. Read our privacy policy & user agreement.
Vote to bring Marco Island back to the people. Vote for Councilmen who will listen and seek consent from the people. Vote for Representative government. Vote for Batte, Hall, Neylon and Guidry.
#1 Posted by Hawke1 on January 29, 2008 at 6:46 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Vote to have representation by people who conduct themselves in a professional and open manner. Do not vote for the men who have brought frivolous and expensive lawsuits against our city. Do not vote for men who not only spew half truths but intentionally malign the characters of any one that opposes them. Do not vote for men who bend the truth to fit their agendas. Do not vote for men who carry their dislike of business to the end of trying to harm business on this Island. Do not vote for men who make verbal attacks on their opponent's family in hopes of doing them fiscal harm. Vote for men that would listen to you even if they don't agree with you. Vote for men that have more of vision for Marco Island than just one sewer project. Vote for men that will be honorable and open. Vote for GIBSON,RECKER,TROTTER,and WLADACK
#2 Posted by marcogirl on January 29, 2008 at 8:15 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Marcogirl, you sound so full of hate and spite. Why don't you try promoting your candidates by telling us what it is they will do for us. What are their plans and vision for Marco Island? You get a lot more with sugar and honey then vinigar.
#3 Posted by Hawke1 on January 29, 2008 at 8:18 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Hawke1: The problem is that Msrs. Trotter, Gibson, Waldack and Recker have been saying what they will do. You just haven't been listening or wanted to hear what they have to say. What your slate has been saying is nothing but unsubstantiated statements, solutions that cannot and will not be implemented as they cannot be and your slate is a group of candidates that have shown by the debates that they don't have a clue as to Marco's past or Marco's future. And Butch is the worst violator. Mark these words. If they should win, they will have my support. But I guarantee that they will not be able to do what they have promised as they are pipe dreams.
Ed Issler
#4 Posted by lauralbi1 on January 29, 2008 at 8:57 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Tell me lauralbi1, what is it Recter is going to do for us? I know he is going to bring some kids to the meetings and that he will finish the sewer, but what is he going to do for us, the residents of the neighborhoods, the taxpayers and the property owners?
#5 Posted by Hawke1 on January 29, 2008 at 12:50 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Post your comment
(Requires free registration.)