Marriage amendment (man and woman) prompts rally in Collier, south Lee

Church groups propose changing Florida’s Constitution to prohibit gay marriage

Andrew McGuire, 42, Janet Knudson, 61 and Riley McGuire, 11, from San Marco Catholic Church on Marco Island seek support for Amendment 2 to make same sex marriages unconstitutional in Florida. A group of about 12 supporters for the Florida Marriage Protection Amendment weathered the heat Saturday at the corner of Bald Eagle Drive and North Collier Boulevard to draw awareness to the amendment which will be on Florida ballots this fall.

Photo by KELLY FARRELL, Staff // Buy this photo

Andrew McGuire, 42, Janet Knudson, 61 and Riley McGuire, 11, from San Marco Catholic Church on Marco Island seek support for Amendment 2 to make same sex marriages unconstitutional in Florida. A group of about 12 supporters for the Florida Marriage Protection Amendment weathered the heat Saturday at the corner of Bald Eagle Drive and North Collier Boulevard to draw awareness to the amendment which will be on Florida ballots this fall.

Andrew McGuire, 42, Janet Knudson, 61 and Riley McGuire, 11, from San Marco Catholic Church on Marco Island seek support for Amendment 2 to make same sex marriages unconstitutional in Florida. A group of about 12 supporters for the Florida Marriage Protection Amendment weathered the heat Saturday at the corner of Bald Eagle Drive and North Collier Boulevard to draw awareness to the amendment which will be on Florida ballots this fall.

Photo by KELLY FARRELL, Staff // Buy this photo

Andrew McGuire, 42, Janet Knudson, 61 and Riley McGuire, 11, from San Marco Catholic Church on Marco Island seek support for Amendment 2 to make same sex marriages unconstitutional in Florida. A group of about 12 supporters for the Florida Marriage Protection Amendment weathered the heat Saturday at the corner of Bald Eagle Drive and North Collier Boulevard to draw awareness to the amendment which will be on Florida ballots this fall.

The presidential race isn’t the only political issue concerning voters as they prepare for November’s election.

Dozens of political activists concerned about the sanctity of marriage were out Saturday at major intersections throughout Collier County, spreading the word about Amendment 2.

Southwest Florida residents holding signs reading “yes 2 marriage; yes on 2” were as far south as Marco Island and as far north as Bonita Beach Road, hoping to garner honks of approval by passersby.

Similar events were scheduled throughout the state to inform people about Amendment 2.

The proposed amendment, also known as the Florida Marriage Protection Amendment, states that “marriage is the legal union of only one man and one woman as husband and wife.”

It also states “no other legal union that is treated as marriage or the substantial equivalent thereof shall be valid or recognized.”

Florida law now makes gay or same-sex marriages illegal.

Some organizations, including Parents, Family and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (PFLAG), oppose the amendment because it will take away rights from domestic partners, both gay and straight, said Gabrielle Gilmore, the organization’s Naples-area president.

That argument didn’t deter the sign-wielders throughout Southwest Florida.

“We’re not trying to change anything. We’re just trying to nail it down by adding it to our constitution so a judge can’t change it,” explained Andrew McGuire, 42, of Marco Island’s San Marco Catholic Church as he hammered a sign reading “Yes on 2” into the grass.

McGuire was joined by 10 other members of his church who handed out pamphlets to passersby at the intersection of Bald Eagle Drive and Collier Boulevard, urging them to amend the Florida Constitution.

McGuire came with four of his children, ages 2 to 11, along with church members as old as 83 sweltering in the midday sun near a sign reading “Honk if you are for marriage.”

“Only mad dogs, Englishmen and concerned Christians go out in the noon-day sun,” said Islander Patricia D’Ambrosio, 79, supporting the new amendment.

Joe Kilroy, 83, and Marie Kilroy, 82, said they heard about the efforts from San Marco Catholic Church. The couple, married 52 years, stood on the hot pavement to show that they “very much support marriage.”

Janet Knudson, 61, encouraged voters to inform themselves on the issue and expressed her support for Amendment 2.

“I’m against gay marriage and the direction of the gay community... I think it’s sad we even need an amendment about a state of being in life that has been held sacred for people through the centuries,” Knudson said.

Adrian Michell, 58, stood near the intersection of Goodlette-Frank and Pine Ridge roads, braving the sun with Joe Hennessy, 75, where each held up a banner that said “Yes on 2” and “honk if you support marriage.”

Florida’s existing law that marriage is between a man and a woman needs to be protected in the Florida Constitution, Michell said.

The fear is that the existing Florida law that defines marriage as being between a man and a woman will get shot down by a judge, similar to what happened in California and Massachusetts.

“We want it enshrined in the constitution,” Michell said. “I think it is getting a lot of support. It basically stands up to the human psyche that marriage is between a man and a woman.”

Lou DePrisco, 77, a member of St. William Catholic Church with Michell, held up the American flag at the small rally.

“I like to do that,” he said of holding up the flag.

He’s confident the amendment will pass once people realize its intent.

“It is so basic to our culture,” he said. “That’s not to say other people should not have rights but marriage is between a man and a woman.”

Saturday’s activists represented several Collier County churches, including St. Peter the Apostle Catholic Church in East Naples, First Baptist Church in North Naples, St. Agnes Mission Catholic Church in North Naples and St. Ann Catholic Parish in Naples.

Voters may expect to hear more about Amendment 2 before they hit the polls in November.

“This is a very dangerous amendment. Domestic partnerships will be done away with across the state affecting people’s benefits,” said Doug Ball, co-chair of Southwest Florida Fairness for All Families.

Ball said he interprets the language differently and suggests voters should vote “no” on their ballots.

“If you really want to protect marriage, eliminate divorce,” said Ruth Dorfman, PFLAG vice president, adding that the government “does not belong in relationships among consenting adults.”

Amendment 2 needs approval from 60 percent of Florida voters to pass.

© 2008 marconews.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Stories

Comments » 9

FlaMike writes:

How sad to see people want to discriminate against people who only want to marry the person they love and start a stable family relationship. One has to wonder why these people hate marriage so much and don't want others to participate. I guess that's what ignorance does.

mferr writes:

It's always interesting to see self proclaimed Christians take the side of discrimination. If I were a member of those churches I would feel ashamed of my affilitation.

Bessier writes:

I think same-sex marriage is OK. Same-sex couples are just as committed in their romantic relationships as heterosexual couples, say researchers who have studied the quality of adult relationships and healthy development. I have a friend getting married with the same sex under the help of the site *BiLoves dotcom*. And they live happily and wonderfully.

maharg writes:

Terri Shiavo, stem cell research ban etc.; look for more of this religious intrusion if you vote for McCain/Palin.

OldMarcoMan writes:

Let Gays get Married, why should they be happy!

Marcosnook03 writes:

Gays,
I hate to break it to you. Marriage isn't what it's cracked up to be. If you want to do it anyways, go for it!!! But I told you so.

happyonmarco writes:

Was the gay-pride umbrella in the background planned?

CEQ15 writes:

LOL #7, good observation!

hourigan82247 writes:

#1 is it FlaMike or FlaMing? Bet you feel alot better out of the closet! We're proud of you!

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.

Features