Brent Batten: Stimulus dollars sent to Marco rerouted to North Florida apartments


The president invites us to follow the money from the federal stimulus package.

In the case of almost $2 million for low-income housing, you’ll need a compass and a road map.

A handful of grants under the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Section 8 housing program will need to make an arduous trek from Washington, D.C., to Marco Island, through Miami, Miramar and back to Southwest Florida before ending up in North Florida.

The journey begins with a visit to, the Web site set up to help the public track $787 billion to be spent through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act passed in February.

Zooming in on Collier County, you’ll find a dot on Marco Island. What stimulus money flows there? Four grants totaling $1.9 million to the businesses Haven Glen Springs, Haven Marion Manor, Haven Havana Heights and THE Apartments. The grants are each described as part of the HUD Section 8 housing assistance payment program.

But none of the named businesses are on Marco Island. All four grants are going to the same post office box on the island.

The businesses also have the same manager, Harris Millman, who lists a North Miami Beach address on state business records.

Millman is also the manager of Haven Economic Development Inc., also of the North Miami Beach address, according to state records.

Numbers provided by directory assistance for Haven Economic Development in Miami and Miramar have been disconnected, as have two other east coast listings available for Harris Millman.

Any Haven Economic Development Inc. activity here is under the official radar.

“They may be doing good work, but I’m not familiar with them,” Marco Island City Manager Steve Thompson said.

Essie Seratta heads up the Collier County Housing Authority, which handles all Section 8 housing vouchers flowing into the county. She said she recently became aware of the grants to Haven Economic’s properties.

“It was very surprising to us to learn another entity’s receiving stimulus money,” she said.

Even more surprising, the money sent to Marco Island is apparently destined to dilapidated apartment complexes in Gainesville, Ocala and Starke.

The HUD Section 8 program consists of two components, explained Gloria Shanahan, a HUD spokeswoman based in Miami. The first provides vouchers that allow low-income, disabled and elderly people to obtain housing. The second supplies money to housing projects that cater to those groups.

In May, the Gainesville Sun reported that Glen Springs apartments in Gainesville, Marion Manor apartments in Ocala and THE Apartments in Starke, all of them accepting section 8 vouchers, were on the verge of losing their contracts with the federal government because of the poor conditions of the units. The Havana Heights apartment complex, located in Havana, Fla., north of Tallahassee, was not mentioned.

Employees who answered the phones at the apartment complexes said Millman was not on site and referred calls to Property Counselors Management Group, a Fort Myers company listed on HUD records as the complexes’ manager. Terry Wayland, named by HUD as the contact person for Property Counselors, did not return phone calls seeking comment.

Andrea Mead, a HUD spokeswoman in Washington, said HUD wouldn’t have issued the recent grants to the North Florida properties unless their contracts were still in effect. HUD will check to make sure the Section 8 money is spent properly, Mead said.

“There is a system in place to monitor each grant and each contract,” she said.

Seratta said she’s concerned HUD money sent to Collier County but intended for use elsewhere could make it more difficult for Collier’s housing authority to get future grants, but Mead said the Section 8 program doesn’t operate on a per county basis.

So following .00024 percent of the total stimulus money leads to a company that doesn’t maintain a working phone listing, owns run-down apartments and has millions of taxpayer dollars sent to a post office box hundreds of miles from the spots where they could possibly do some good. Stimulating.

Connect with Brent Batten at

© 2009 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Stories

Related Links

Comments » 3

sailingby writes:

You might want to keep the magnifying glass on this one...their website
states that do to economic conditions, all business of this enterprise has ceased. The website lists Collier County as an area in which it was doing business.

Also of curious interest,
16105 NE 18 AVE
N. MIAMI BEACH FL 33162 was also the principal agent for Haven Investments from 1996, inactivated September 2009.

u2cane writes:

Probably a donor to Obama, change, yes change in where the money is flowing. We need real change, we need to get the crooks out of Washington. We need to change the way the system is set up and we need to change the people in the Congress and Senate. We need term limits and honest people working in government instead of career politicians. We need change, but many of you were duped by Obama into what kind of change.

happy6 writes:

u2cane...forget it...te dems have control and are winning prizes..nobel....for doing nothing...they have forgotten the town halls during have the republicans...they are all a joke...when you go to the polls if it says incumabant....pick the one before or after on the list....we can't do worse.
then you have the idiotic city council on marco...what a joke they are...the entore bunch...what we actually have is arceri, issler, lazzarus and moss as council people....wal-duck is still trying to find a place to live after the bank kicks hom out of his mothers house. the whole freakin' island is a joke....sorry i live here..wish i could sell out.

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.