Berkshire Lakes neighbors band together to oppose school rezoning

Then, at 6 p.m., the Daily News will stream live a meeting about school rezoning in Collier County from Golden Gate High School. Area students plan to attend the meeting to speak out against the plan designed to comply with the class­size amendment. Watch it live and join the discussion at Click here to learn more about the school rezoning issue »

— Their reasons may differ, but they all agree on one thing: The residents of the Berkshire Lakes neighborhood don’t want their community to be re-zoned from the Naples High School District to the Lely High School district.

Members of the Berkshire Lakes neighborhood voiced their concerns and opinions about the Collier County School District’s recent decision to rezone the county’s high schools at a meeting Tuesday night at the community’s clubhouse.

The district wants to rezone 210 students — 154 from Naples High School and 56 from Golden Gate High School — to Lely High School next year. The Collier County School Board voted to rezone its schools in order to meet regulations under the state’s class size amendment. The School Board decided against purchasing portable classrooms for schools that would need extra space because they would cost $3 million. The district must meet the minimum class sizes by fall 2010.

Many of the neighborhood’s residents agreed the amount of students attending Naples High School by choice, out-of-zone requests or illegally, is a problem.

According to figures presented by the district, Naples High School gets about 50 students through choice and out-of-zone requests, which is a third of the students that will be rezoned from Naples High to Lely. That figure does not include the number of students who might be using a family member or a close friend’s home address as their own address so they can attend their school of choice.

“It is wrong to give that choice and then rezone a bunch of other kids,” said Collier County Commissioner Tom Henning, who attended the meeting. “We all are parents before anything else, and that’s what I am. I am a parent of a 7-year-old child, who goes to Osceola (Elementary) School that is according to the (rezoning) maps going to go to Golden Gate Elementary.”

The community members wondered why the district is disrupting several school zones instead of one, and why they are not using the vacant portable at Calusa Park Elementary School.

“Let’s move portables rather than lives,” said Bert Cleland, a Berkshire Lakes resident who helped run the meeting.

Henning — who lives in The Shores, a community located across Santa Barbara Boulevard from Berkshire Lakes — urged the two neighborhoods to work together in their effort to change the proposed rezoning.

“I think we ought to work together,” Commissioner Henning said.

Other Berkshire residents were concerned that the property value of their homes would drop due the rezoning, but they concluded that the Collier County School Board members probably would not consider property values in their decision.

“One of our personal concerns is just property value,” said Mark Snider, a Berkshire Lakes resident, who has a 15-year-old son attending Naples High School. Snider said he lives in a family-sized home with a big back yard that would most likely be sold to another family.

“Since it’s going to have a real impact on people, and I don’t care how you shake it and bake it: this is pretty serious,” Snider said.

© 2010 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Stories

Comments » 1

brs555 writes:


The Logan Woods neighborhood is meeting to
discuss the proposed school rezoning.

The school rezoning proposal calls for our children to be rezoned to Golden Gate Elementary and Naples High School. This rezoning could have a detrimental effect on our children’s education and on our property values.

• The disheveling and displacement of our children from Golden Gate Elementary to Oakridge Middle School to Naples High School which does not provide continuity in their educational process. (Currently our children are zoned from Osceola Elementary to Oakridge M.S. to Gulf Coast H.S.)
• A huge negative impact on property values throughout our community at a time
when our community is already suffering from the economic downturn.
• Given that the current proposal would send our students to a Title 1 school which
has been identified as a School in Need of Improvement, by law our students would be eligible to attend another school, thereby circumventing the rezoning proposal.

For information and maps regarding the rezoning go to
We need your support! Please come with constructive ideas and alternatives to the proposed plan.

When: Friday, January 15th
6 – 8 p.m.

Where: Vineyards Park Community Center
6231 Arbor Blvd.
Room A

Please email the school board members to let them know you are a resident of Logan Woods and that you oppose the proposed rezoning.
School Board Members
Steve Donovan
Pat Carroll
Kathleen Curatolo
Julie Sprague

Questions, please contact Randy Durham at 269-6408 or

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.