Marco Marriott’s expansion plan not popular with neighbors

— Marco Island Marriott Beach Resort & Spa’s proposal to try movin’ on up to the east side of Collier Boulevard isn’t making all the neighbors happy.

The fear from one side of the street is the creation of a canyon of concrete with nothing but sky visible above. On the other side of the street, economics is the impetus for the 138,000-square-foot convention center, said Rick Medwedeff, general manager of the Marco Marriott.

MassMutual Financial Group, which owns the hotel property, made a promise to the community in 2001 not to build on the east side of Collier Boulevard and that needs to be upheld, said Bob Olson, who lives near the proposed site.

“In a stealth move, at a June 25 Planning Board meeting, without anyone’s knowledge, not even the Planning Board’s knowledge, they came back to do this again,” Olson said.

Who else but a big business could get scheduled to make a presentation to the Planning Board without telling the board in advance what the topic was? Olson pondered aloud.

The proposers never mentioned their contractual promise during the “sleuth Planning Board meeting,” he said.

This isn’t the open government that City Council Chairman Frank Recker and City Manager Jim Riviere promised, Olson said.

The 2001 Planned Unit Development agreement states that the hotel is not to build on the east side of Collier Boulevard.

“That’s a hurdle that definitely needs to be addressed,” Medwedeff said. “The first phase of this was to get a sense of the appetite for reconsidering those restrictions.”

Creating jobs, increasing the tax base and a large overall economic boost for the community are among the reasons why Medwedeff said people may be more amenable to the idea than they were nine years ago.

There is a six-story building to the north of the proposed site and a five-story building to the south, so there shouldn’t be an objection to a four-story structure, Medwedeff said.

“Businesses feed off my hotel guests,’’ he said, alluding to restaurants, boating, fishing, retail and other area vendors.

The added conference rooms will increase tourism during the non-peak times, he said.

“It’s a win for Marco Island and beyond, for Naples, for Collier County and for the Everglades,’’ he said. “They really need the business.”

Consideration by the city of Marco Island is in its early stages, city planner Kris Van Lengen said.

A publicly advertised Planning Board meeting and two subsequent meetings before City Council are yet to be scheduled.

“I must confess that I’m anxious to see the Marriott proposal formally presented,” Recker said.

The Marriott brand would have a huge commercial benefit, while the expansion contributes more taxes, taking the burdens off others, Recker said.

The project could create hundreds of construction jobs and create 80 permanent jobs, Medwedeff estimated in preliminarily predictions.

“It will be a matter of millions and millions of dollars to the area economy,” he said.

MassMutual has yet to commit approximately $70 million to build the meeting space.

The 162 homeowners who signed the original petitions to restrict construction on the east side of Collier Boulevard aren’t changing their minds, said Olson, who vowed to represent them in 2001.

“I really do want to be a good neighbor. I don’t want to create the fire storm we created in 2000,” Olson said. “But this is black-and-white. We have to obey the laws. So should a big company.”

He and residents of San Marco Villas, as well as Royal Seafarer Condos, have backyard sunset views and sea breezes at stake, Olson said.

“I don’t have a desire to hear screeching cars and car horns 30 feet from my house,” he said.

© 2010 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Topics

Related Stories

Related Links

Comments » 7

cmonmanreally writes:

Mr. Olsen, like other neighbors in that part of the island, should have expected that corporate America would take over. Mr. Olsen you are a d-bag!

lauralbi1 writes:

Boy it is amazing when people get emotional. I lived in Sam Marco Villas and I know for a fact that this proposal will not impact the views from this building at all. I think the same can be said for the Royal Seafarer, also. I can look at the picturte and plan from the previous article on this subject and see that this is the case. But I would also like to wait to see the details.
PUD's can and have been changed inb almost every example of one that has been done on Marco Island.
Right or wrong, it is commonplace based on the economy and Island situation.
And appearing before the Planning Commission. Anyone of us can do that and present something without notice.
But I guarantee anyone concerned that this proposal will get all the input and scrutiny that is required. And I am certain that the Marriott will be very appreciative, as they always have been, for the City to consider their proposal.
The complainers above, has any one of you seen details of what is being proposed ??
Save your concerns until we all see what is in the works.
After all, if this becomes a reality, we will all see the benefit in tax and revenue income to the City.
So don't be so quick to judge. Let's see what is being proposed.
Ed Issler

ed34145 writes:

So much for promises and agreements. MassMutual "bought" the silence of people who objected to their 2001 proposal by promising to NEVER build on that side of Collier.......

Eagleeye writes:

It doesn't matter how much tax revenue any project brings in. The folks who run the city will spend more money than they have. There is zero fiscal discipline on Marco Island.

onlythetruth writes:

Bob Olson is nothing but a malcontent who wants to get something out of all of this. He opposed Medeira, he opposes everything. Not for any real good, but so he can personally benefit.

captnjimbo writes:

With a good set back it might even improve the way things look.

stepuporshutup (Inactive) writes:

BUILD IT! BUILD IT! BUILD IT! Quit the complaining people. Times change and what was said 10 years ago was said 10 years ago. Life moves on and this would be great for the Island. Mass Mutual only needs to offer the adjoining property owners a complimentary good neighbor fee of $25,000 each and you will see how happy they would be to have this built. Once again it is all about what can I get for me.

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.