VIDEO: Smoke out: Naples mayor plans to bring smoking ban for beaches and parks before council again

Ban smoking at Naples beaches?

Hear what beachgoers are saying

Should Naples ban smoking on public beaches?

See the results »

View previous polls »

— A debate over smoking on Naples beaches is once again smoldering.

Naples Mayor Bill Barnett on Wednesday said he plans to ask city staff to look into the feasibility of banning smoking on Naples beaches.

The moves comes two years after City Council rejected an ordinance that would have banned smoking at all city-owned beaches and parks — four beach access points and about 30 parks throughout the city.

That ban also would have included the city’s pier and dock. The vote to turn down the ban was 4-3.

“I haven’t given up,” Barnett said Wednesday. “We were almost there. We were really close.”

Barnett said he made the decision to bring the item back because he has a new City Council, and because he hoped there was more support for the item.

Three of the four people — Councilman Gary Price and councilwomen Teresa Heitmann and Dee Sulick — opposed to the 2008 request are still on Naples City Council.

Barnett first raised the issue in December 2007 and said he had support from the American Cancer Society.

Though Barnett said second-hand smoke was a concern, he was especially concerned about littering that comes from people tossing their butts in the sand.

Barnett stood by that position Wednesday, saying his request was “more environmental” than against smokers.

“I’m considerate of smokers,” he said. “They deserve a place to smoke.”

While Barnett’s 2008 request is the most recent attempt to ban smoking on the beach, city officials are no strangers to this request.

In early 2002, the city’s community services advisory board was behind a request to ban smoking in the city’s parks. When the issue came before council that March, council members learned the city already had the authority to ban smoking in parks.

The ordinance has been on the books since 1957.

Barnett said Wednesday he hoped City Council would be able to discuss the ban sometime this fall. He said he was hopeful the ban would pass this time around.

“This is my last shot,” he said.

Connect with Naples reporter Jenna Buzzacco-Foerster at

© 2010 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Stories

Comments » 4

JLinendoll writes:

I am so tired of walking or sitting on the beach and having smoke blowing in my direction! I haved moved several times in a day and still have smoke blown on me by people walking by. This makes my eyes run and I have difficulty breathing. I think there should be a designated area for smokers or a complete ban. Why should I always be the one to have to move when the smokers are the offending party!

harleyrider1978 writes:

This ban proposal is also weird to see, since Florida state law clearly pre-empts local communities from enacting stricter bans than state law. There is NO DOUBT that this is a sneaky attack on smokers, and they should not hesitate to file a lawsuit citing the Florida state law prohibiting local bans from being stricter, if it passes. "This legislation expressly preempts regulation of smoking to the state and supersedes any municipal or county ordinance on the subject".:

JLinendoll writes:

Again, Being around smoke even at a distance causes me many health problems and is life threatening to my grandson who has asthma!

extra234 (Inactive) writes:

Then I guess you need to surround yourselves in a plastic bubble since it is not the entire world's responsibility to placate you.

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.