New Collier superintendent wants more time off, no chance of reassignment

Kamela Patton, new superintendent Collier County Public Schools on NewsMakers 5-8-11

Kamela Patton, new superintendent Collier County Public Schools on NewsMakers 5-8-11

Pat Carroll on NewsMakers

— From more vacation days and technology in her office, home and car, to a guarantee that she won’t be reassigned, Collier County’s new superintendent, Kamela Patton, has made her requests.

Now it is time for the Collier County School Board to decide if they can live with them.

The board will hold a special meeting Thursday to discuss revisions to Patton’s contract after she proposed extensive changes.

Among those changes:

■ An increase in vacation days from 20 to 25.

■ An increase in sick days from 16 over the course of a year to 18 up front.

■ Add six personal days. The initial contract had no personal days.

■ An increase in the automobile allowance from $500 to $750 per month.

■ District pays for and provides technology equipment, as Patton requests, for use in her office, residence and automobile for the conduct of her duties, and for “incidental personal use.”

■ The School Board cannot reassign Patton from her position as superintendent to another position without her written consent.

District Attorney Jon Fishbane, who held a conference call with Patton and her attorney Wednesday, said some of what Patton has proposed is already being revised.

Fishbane said a request from Patton that the district put $12,000 in a tax shelter or annuity has been withdrawn. In addition, he said, Patton has agreed to abide by the district’s policy that personal days are taken from an employee’s accrued sick days.

Fishbane said he planned to make some of those changes and present a revised contract to board members prior to their meeting Thursday.

“These are resolvable issues we have to work through,” he said.

Attempts to reach Patton for comment were unsuccessful.

During an interview with Daily News Editorial Page Editor Jeff Lytle this week, School Board member Pat Carroll said she was “disappointed” by Patton’s changes, which could “possibly” be deal breakers.

She said she’s heard that candidates with Ph.Ds are taught to “come back with some sort of amazing counter-offer” to show they have the self esteem required for the job.

“For me, it’s going to determine whether or not she will accept our counter, whether or not she’s here to help Collier County, or for the money,” Carroll said.

Other board members, including School Board Chairwoman Julie Sprague, said they believe a deal will ultimately be reached.

The School Board voted May 5, to offer Patton a three-year- and- one-month contract, which starts June 1, and ends June 30, 2014. She would be paid $200,000 for the first year — a figure that was decided by the board before superintendent candidates’ interviews began.

In addition, Patton would receive a review every six months, with one of those reviews culminating in a yearly evaluation. Her reviews would be based on a set of goals, which are tied to the District’s strategic plan, as well as standards for achieving goals, which are based on the Connect Now statement, an education initiative developed by community members.

Patton would receive 20 working days of vacation per year, at least 10 of which must be used each year or lost. Board members also offered Patton a $500 per month car stipend to cover gas mileage and maintenance of her vehicle, and agreed to pay for Patton to have up to four memberships in professional organizations and attend up to four professional conferences each year.

The district would also give Patton an additional $1,200 to use to join Rotary or other local professional organizations.

In one of the more interesting additions to the contract, Patton added a section on board/superintendent communications.

“The Board and Superintendent agree that they shall work with each other in a spirit of cooperation and team work and shall provide each other with periodic opportunities to discuss Board/Superintendent relations and communications,” reads the section, which also asks that the board and Patton set a date for a first meeting to occur by July 31.

“At that time, the Board and the Superintendent shall meet to discuss the roles of the Board and the Superintendent and to develop a process and procedures by which the Board and the Superintendent will communicate, with an emphasis on productive and constructive communications between the Board and the Superintendent.”

Patton also requests that the board, both collectively and as individual board members, give her criticisms, complaints and suggestions on her performance promptly.

Sprague said the conference call with Patton and her attorney was helpful to the negotiations process.

“I think both sides didn’t understand some of the background of where the other side was coming from,” she said. “It made it much easier to converse and do it.”

Sprague said she thought both sides would be able to come to an agreement “that is clear and readable and will not be picked up three years from now and be interpreted in different ways.”

Part of the reason for the back and forth between Patton and the School Board is that the board and Fishbane developed the contract without initial input from Patton. When Dennis Thompson developed his contract with the board, for example, he and his attorney met with then-School Board member Steve Donovan and then-school District Attorney Richard Withers to develop the contract that was eventually presented to the School Board.

“We are in very different territory,” Sprague said.

Fishbane agreed.

“Everything is transparent so the public knows what was occurring,” he said.

Patton is expected to start work June 1. Sprague said she is “optimistic” that will happen.

Fishbane said the goals of both sides have not changed, including that the new superintendent will start work in two weeks.

“As you can see from the changes she made to the contract, the start date wasn’t one of them,” he said.

The Collier County School Board’s meeting will begin at 5 p.m. Thursday in the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Administrative Center, 5775 Osceola Trail.

Connect with K-12 education policy reporter Katherine Albers at

© 2011 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Stories

Comments » 8

ajm3s writes:

Did they not interview other candidates which met the criteria? Perhaps, it is time to move with an offer to the next candidate, or is Ms Patton so glowingly above the others? My suspicion, she is not. Stay tuned.

dc5799 writes:

Dismiss her now!!!!!

Ocram (Inactive) writes:

School Board, read the writing on the wall before it is too late!

Seawaller writes:

Too many ludicrous proposals to even address. Can her.

RayPray writes:

"Patton graduated from Messiah College in Grantham, Pa., with a bachelor’s degree in elementary education. She earned her master’s in reading from Nova Southeastern University and received her doctorate in educational leadership from the University of Miami."

>>> BA Messiah College? From wiki:

"Following the US Justice Department Scandal in which Messiah College alumna Monica Goodling was intimately involved, several members of the media ridiculed Messiah College. Jon Stewart on The Daily Show referred to Messiah as a school "where people have faith that they'll receive a quality education, and yet somehow it never arrives,"[25] and "that everyone in the God business knows is a 'savior school'.[26] Bill Maher focused his satirical criticism on Goodling's legal education education at Regent University, but also mocked Messiah, calling it "the home of the Fighting Christies."[27]"

>>> MS Nova? (Online?)

>>> Educational Leadership PhD?

>>> Is there nobody in Florida with legitimate or plausible credentials?

Ocram (Inactive) writes:

in response to MarcoIslandWoman:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Fresh blood with no credentials. Getting to sound very familiar around here!

Ocram (Inactive) writes:

in response to MarcoIslandWoman:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Boy, the truth really gets your goat. Why don't you learn to keep your "traitor" mouth shut.

u2cane writes:

in response to MarcoIslandWoman:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

The great thing about America is we allow you to express your s----- thoughts, no matter how moronic. If you were in Germany you would have disappeared already.

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.