Six months down, six to go? Ex-sheriff Hunter hits half-year as Marco police chief

Scott McIntyre/Staff 
Marco Police Chief Don Hunter, left, goes over various documents with Capt. Dave Baer during a status report meeting for the past year of police actions in Hunter's office.

Photo by SCOTT MCINTYRE

Scott McIntyre/Staff Marco Police Chief Don Hunter, left, goes over various documents with Capt. Dave Baer during a status report meeting for the past year of police actions in Hunter's office.

— Six months after former Collier County Sheriff Don Hunter was sworn in as Marco Island's police chief, the question of how is he doing, is joined by another – how long will he be doing it?

Hunter acknowledged the rumors swirling in the city that when his contract is up in August, he may not renew it.

"I may have started those rumors myself," Hunter said. "I said my contract is for one year, in talking to some people. It's an open question. If I feel I can do something important, I might stay on. I also have an interest in starting my own business."

The nature of that potential business venture, "I'm not at liberty to say," he said. "I have a partner."

Being chief of a department with 33 sworn officers is a far cry from running the Sheriff's Office, which, Hunter said, had as many as 1,392 full-time employees, plus reserve officers, at the peak of his 16-year tenure.

Where an elected sheriff answers to the voters, having thousands of bosses is much like having no boss at all, while as police chief, he is a city department head with the city manager as his boss. In the sheriff's job, he faced the voters every four years.

Now he answers to City Manager Jim Riviere, and indirectly, the Marco Island City Council. Riviere wasn't immediately available for comment regarding Hunter. Council Chairman Jerry Gibson had little to say about Hunter, who came aboard in August as a 59-year-old chief with a base salary of $100,000.

"I have no thoughts," Gibson said. "As a city councilman, we don't get too involved in personnel issues."

He said he's aware of the talk of Hunter leaving.

"I heard people who heard him say it. Maybe that was his intention," he said.

Council Vice Chairman Larry Magel also heard the rumors, and also had little feedback to offer: "I asked the city manager if Chief Hunter was leaving, and he said that's not his understanding."

Sandi Riedemann, executive director of the Marco Island Area Chamber of Commerce, had little to say on the subject. One island leader who did have a reaction to Hunter's tenure was Fay Biles, president of the Marco Island Taxpayers' Association. A fierce opponent of what she sees as wasteful city spending, she is firmly in Hunter's corner.

"I think he's a wonderful chief of police," said Biles, who has known Hunter for years. "He does his homework, checks into everything, and never makes a comment until he has all the facts."

Hunter said the Marco police department is running smoothly, and he hasn't made any major changes in its operations.

Scott McIntyre/Staff 
 A Marco Island Police hat sits on a shelf while Marco Police Chief Don Hunter goes over various documents with Capt. Dave Baer during a status report meeting for the past year of police actions in Hunter's office on Wednesday.

Photo by SCOTT MCINTYRE

Scott McIntyre/Staff A Marco Island Police hat sits on a shelf while Marco Police Chief Don Hunter goes over various documents with Capt. Dave Baer during a status report meeting for the past year of police actions in Hunter's office on Wednesday.

"I've been reluctant to make changes of substance. I'm learning who are the top performers. (Former Marco Police Chief) Thom Carr left the agency in pretty good stead."

Their greatest strength, he said, is in the core of well-seasoned officers.

"Clearly, our strength is the large cadre of experienced people we have. Virtually all our officers have extensive careers elsewhere," he said.

That experience extends to the chief, whose many years in law enforcement in this area give him connections in the Sheriff's Office as well as with state and federal agencies.

"We've called on the Sheriff's Office for added assistance" when needed, Hunter said. "We had a string of burglaries in August, and they placed undercover elements, and sent in a SET (special enforcement) team."

The sheriff's aviation unit, he said, helped capture a suspect who crashed a vehicle and fled the scene.

But in general, Marco Island doesn't have much crime.

"We had a total of 168 crimes last year" on Marco Island, said Hunter, "an average of less than one a day."

As county sheriff, he dealt with more than 6,000 crimes per year.

"Here, it's more traffic, congestion, and crowd control," he said.Hunter praised his second-in-command, Capt. Dave Baer, and Baer returned the compliment.

"I'm glad he's here," Baer said. "He's done a lot in budgetary review, and he took the lead in vehicle replacement issues. We're working on a new evidence and property management system."

Baer said Hunter has avoided making "flashy changes," a mistake made by some chief executives moving into a new organization.

"People want to see visible change, but we didn't need a new coat of paint," Baer said.

Hunter said he didn't mind the commute from his North Naples home, although spending time with his wife, Melissa, and their daughters is a priority.

"I make quite a few phone calls, and coming home, it gives me time to decompress."

And so far, he hasn't given in to the temptation to make the run on his Harley-Davidson Softail Deluxe, Hunter said.

© 2012 marconews.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Topics

Related Stories

Related Links

Comments » 11

ed34145 writes:

How come Riviere is NEVER available for comment...or anything else?

Throat_Yogurt writes:

what is Hunter's salary for this year?

marco826 writes:

in response to GorchFock:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Agree, 33 is too many.
Could be cut by 1/3rd.

marco826 writes:

In 2010, Marco population was over 16,000. A common formula is 2 officers for every 1000 citizens. Hence we have 32. That being said,the average age today of Marco's citizens is 60 years old. Safe to say, generally not your criminal types. Add in the other law enforcement support for this island and it's easy to see that we could and should make some cuts. Klaus is not out of line. Finally, most 60 year olds are too tired to commit a crime...of course they do bump into parked cars a bit...

ed34145 writes:

60 years old may not be the "criminal type", but they have much more need of protection, health issues, etc. They are the ones who are often preyed on by the criminal type.

Throat_Yogurt writes:

in response to GorchFock:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

Yes, possibly some educated ones too instead of those double dipping fat basstards

26yearsonmarco writes:

You are all missing the most important crime of all on Marco Island which is the "Rolling Stop Crime" at intersections. Since I received a Warning, I stop and count to TEN at every stop sign especially the one at Collier and Winterberry where you will see two Cop Cars parked in the shade alongside the 7/11 every day. It can be difficult being a Law Abiding Citizen, and the horns blowing behind can get annoying at times.

MIslander writes:

As evidenced by this article- if there is ever serious crime on Marco Island, the MIPD calls the sheriff office for help. Please let's merge the MIPD back with the CCSO and call it a day!

The Marco Island police are EXTREMELY overpaid security guards, that cost tax payers millions in their pensions and never ending lawsuits!

26yearsonmarco writes:

in response to MIslander:

As evidenced by this article- if there is ever serious crime on Marco Island, the MIPD calls the sheriff office for help. Please let's merge the MIPD back with the CCSO and call it a day!

The Marco Island police are EXTREMELY overpaid security guards, that cost tax payers millions in their pensions and never ending lawsuits!

You are 100 percent right. Return ALL services back to the County, ie: Building Dept., Code Enforcement, etc., etc. We are being double taxed for services that were handled by the County for years.

marco97 writes:

26years,
The MIPD should not even be allowed to give tickets for rolling stops, they are the worst offenders. I almost always make a full stop at a stop sign and always use my directionals even when other cars are not around. I do this to set an example for my children who will be driving soon. Unfortunately the MIPD does not set a good example, I thought this would change under Hunter but I guess not. And for all the people on this island who need to have a cell phone glued to your ear, get a bluetooth so you will be able to use both hands and your directionals.

marconed writes:

I think Don is doing a fine job,what with he has to deal with. He has to hire back a moron who was previosly let go.He cant fire a couple other idiots who shouldnt even be able to wear a badge. He has to deal with a force twice as big as needed, I wouldnt blame him for leaving especially having to deal with this city council. He deserves much better than this

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.

Features