New city council seated, city manager receives three 'no confidence' votes

cheryl ferrara/eagle correspondent (4)
Marco Island's four newly elected city councilors, from left, Larry Sacher, Amadeo Petricca, Larry Honig and Ken Honecker, take the oath of office Monday prior to the city council meeting.

cheryl ferrara/eagle correspondent (4) Marco Island's four newly elected city councilors, from left, Larry Sacher, Amadeo Petricca, Larry Honig and Ken Honecker, take the oath of office Monday prior to the city council meeting.

Applause greeted Marco Island’s new city councilors Monday and its new leadership. Councilor Joe Batte was elected chairman and newly elected Councilor Ken Honecker became vice chairman.

Shortly after a "coffee and cake" celebration, it was back to work with nearly 4 hours of council business. As council completed its agenda, City Manager Jim Riviere said it was time for council to decide if it wanted to keep him.

Riviere became the city's manager after an interim period as acting manager. Two years ago, he agreed to take a permanent position, but said he would only make the commitment until this election.

Monday night, Riviere said he would like to continue as city manager, but derogatory comments that surfaced during the election left him feeling like he was "on thin ice." He said it was unfair to city staff when the fate of the manager was uncertain.

Councilor Chick Kiester moved for a vote of confidence in the city manager. Newly elected Councilor Larry Sacher argued the time was not right for such a vote and suggested a written review of the manager precede the discussion.

"I'm uncomfortable with the question after 11 hours on the job," he said. "I would like to see a formal evaluation rather than an informal vote of confidence."

Councilor Larry Magel moved discussion forward saying comments made by council-elects were already affecting staff.

"There's no reason to duck this question," he countered.

The confidence vote passed 4-3 with three of the four newly elected councilors – Sacher, Amadeo Petricca and Honecker – opposed. Councilor Larry Honig voted with the majority.

Council also discussed appointments to county and city boards. By consensus, councilors representing Marco Island on county boards are Sacher on the Tourist Development Council, Kiester on the Metropolitan Planning Organization and Honig on the Coastal Advisory Committee.

Council approached appointing city boards with some confusion. After prior elections held in March, appointments were made for terms starting in June. Because 2012 elections were moved to November, board members previously appointed were asked to stay on from June to November until the new council was seated.

Honig moved all boards continue to operate with current members until new appointments could be finalized. The vote passed 5-2. The city will advertise for resumes of interested residents, and council will discuss the make-up and responsibilities of boards at its December workshop.

Council agreed on first reading to pass an ordinance that would reduce impact fees for existing commercial renovations. Joe Irvin, city zoning administrator, said the reduction would have a minor impact on capital projects for the Fire and Police Departments.

In the proposal, the city would sunset its fee reductions in parallel with a similar program in Collier County. Council will hold a second reading on the ordinance at a future meeting.

Councilors tabled a proposed amendment to the Land Development Code that would restrict certain types of advertising signs. Burt Saunders, city attorney, informed council recent litigation may have made banning the signs illegal. Council will research the issue for a future meeting.

Ed Skrzynski, owner of Marco Canvas and creator of a mooring boat cover assist system, made a presentation to council on his product. The cover system uses transoms and belly bands to aid operation and secure canvas to vessels.

The system is designed to handle hurricane force winds up to 140 mph and can be operated in minutes without heavy lifting, Skrzynski said. Marco Island's Planning Board recommended the mooring system be added to Chapter 54 of Marco Island's Code of Ordinances as an acceptable boat over alternative.

City staff suggested installation of the system should require an $85 permit and restrictions in color. The Planning Board had approved a motion to bring the item to city council without restrictions or permits.

Council voted 6-1 to accept on first reading the ordinance as presented by the Planning Board with no restrictions or permitting. Magel voted against the motion. A second reading will be scheduled for a future date.

Council rescheduled its workshop from Dec. 10 to Dec. 20. The workshop will be held from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. in the Community Meeting Room, 51 Bald Eagle Drive. If council plans to vote on any issues, it will also call a special council meeting during the workshop.

© 2012 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Topics

Comments » 11

RayPray writes:

Unconscionable for these three guys to vote against someone with an esteemed surfboard PhD!

"He said it was unfair to city staff when the fate of the manager was uncertain."

Unfairness to slaving away & miserably remunerated municipal employees must end now!

MrBreeze writes:

The City manager is worried about his future. I think the new guys were very smart in the no vote. Why vote "confidence" when you might not feel that way.

I like our guys and they will do what is right for this island.

That "vote of cofidence" was already casted on Election Day when they won the seats.

JohninMarco writes:

Considering that Kiester and Magil gave the city manager a new 2 year contract prior to the election, I guess the smart thing to do was keep him not pay him to do nothing like THEY did before with Thompson.

MrBreeze writes:

Is a surfboard PhD the same as a Masters of Cavedweller U?

1Paradiselost writes:

We need term limits!

OldMarcoMan writes:

1Paradiselost Councilmen have a two Term Limit and City Manager serves 'At the pleasure' of the Council and can be fired at any time. A typical City Manager in Florida keeps their job from 6 to 8 years,

MrBreeze writes:

This City Manager will not survive the new council unless he starts to reel in spending and downsizing the City Departments.

Start with Code Compliance. This is getting out of hand with fines of 100 per day, rules that counter themselves, regulations that burden the residents. Start there, cut the fat.

mahiman writes:

If he has a new two year contract, give him crappy jobs and make him either work or quit. Hope we don't have to wait for another election to get 3 more idiots out!

NobodysFool57 writes:

What's with the City's preoccupation of replacing perfectly good streetlights with something we have to buy, maintain, and get billed power usage for? I don't see any problem with the utility installed luminaires we currently have on most of our streets. I recently noticed the new fixtures on Park Ave. near Winn-Dixie and a bunch more in a pile behind a building over there. Utility installed lights are supplied with power and maintained for a fixed monthly fee per unit. This looks like just another Public Works boondoggle to me. Get rid of Tim Pinter, he's every bit as bad as Rony Joel ever was.

MrBreeze writes:

Nobodys, You must not forget this is Marco Island the land of wishes and City dreams with the taxpayer dollar. We need pretty lights, and bridges. The problem is who is going to pay for it?

I know the new guys will stop the spending spree.

WizeOlMarco writes:

City staff suggested installation of the system should require an $85 permit...

The City staff wants homeowners to get an $85 permit for a boat cover? They must be kidding.

Share your thoughts

Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.

Comments can be shared on Facebook and Yahoo!. Add both options by connecting your profiles.