WASHINGTON — Just which 47 percent of Americans was Mitt Romney talking about? It's hard to say. He lumped together three different ways of sorting people in what he's called less-than-elegant remarks.
Each of those three groups — likely Obama voters, people who get federal benefits and people who don't pay federal income taxes — contains just under half of all Americans, in the neighborhood of 47 percent at a given moment. There's some overlap, but the three groups are quite distinct.
Confusingly, Romney spoke as if they're made up of the same batch of Americans.
A look at the three groups:
OBAMA VOTERS
What Romney said: "There are 47 percent of the people who will vote for the president no matter what."
He's right on the nose, according to the latest Associated Press-GfK poll: Forty-seven percent of likely voters say they support Obama. And 46 percent say they support Romney, essentially a tie. This number fluctuates from poll to poll and week to week and could shift substantially before Election Day.
Who they are:
■ Most are employed: Sixty-two percent of the Obama voters work, including the 10 percent working only part time. A fourth are retired. Five percent say they're temporarily unemployed.
■ Most earn higher-than-average wages. Fifty-six percent have household incomes above the U.S. median of $50,000. Just 16 percent have incomes below $30,000, and about the same share (20 percent) have incomes of $100,000 or more.
■ They're all ages but skew younger than Romney's voters: Twenty percent are senior citizens and 12 percent are under age 30.
■ They're more educated than the overall population: Forty-three percent boast four-year college degrees or above; 21 percent topped out with a high school diploma.
PEOPLE WHO GET FEDERAL BENEFITS
What Romney said: "There are 47 percent ... who are dependent on government ... who believe they are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you name it."
Whether they are dependent and believe they are entitled to anything is arguable, but Romney's statistic is about right — 49 percent of the U.S. population receive some kind of federal benefits, including Social Security and Medicare, according to the most recent Census Bureau data. Looking only at people who receive benefits that are based on financial need, such as food stamps, the portion is smaller — just over a third of the population. Many people get more than one type of benefit.
The biggest programs and their percentage of the U.S. population:
■ Medicaid: 26 percent
■ Social Security: 16 percent
■ Food stamps: 16 percent
■ Medicare: 15 percent
■ Women, Infants and Children food program: 8 percent
THOSE WHO PAY NO FEDERAL INCOME TAX
What Romney said: "Forty-seven percent of Americans pay no income tax."
Romney's about on target — 46 percent of U.S. households paid no federal income tax last year, according to a study by the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. Most do pay other federal taxes, including Medicare and Social Security withholding. And they're not all poor. Some middle-income and wealthy families escape income tax because of deductions, credits and investment tax preferences.
Why these people don't pay:
■ About half don't earn enough money for a household of their size to owe income tax. For example, a family of four earning less than $26,400 wouldn't pay.
■ About 22 percent get tax breaks for senior citizens that offset their income.
■ About 15 percent get tax breaks for the working poor or low-income parents.
■ Almost 3 percent get tax breaks for college tuition or other education expenses.
Who they are:
■ The vast majority have below-average earnings: Among all who don't owe, 9 out of 10 make $50,000 or less.
■ But some of the wealthy escape taxes, including about 4,000 households earning more than $1 million a year.







Scripps Interactive Newspapers Group
Comments » 16
1Paradiselost writes:
When watching and listing to Romney/Ryan I can only think of one movie, Dumb and Dumber.
I'm just waiting for Romney to pull Ryan's finger. That would just complete it for me.
Can't you Republicans find someone who's not like Richard Nixon?
Mayor_McCheese writes:
Also in the "Non-Federal Income Taxpayer" category are US soldiers who are in combat. Under federal Law and most state laws, US soldiers in combat are exempt from paying tax on the income they earned while in combat.
I wonder how many of our combat soldiers are pleased that they are portrayed by Romney as moochers and victims.
"Inelegant" is one word for it. "Stupid" is another.
Our_world_according_to_zookeeper (Inactive) writes:
http://www.miamiherald.com/2012/09/20...
WhiskeyTangoFoxtrot writes:
1paradise, Bidens a real genius! LOL!
McCheese, US soldiers don't make enough money to have to pay federal income tax. Great point! You are brilliant. I'm not a Romney supporter. Please explain to me how Obama isn't an empty suit? He cannot even form a budget. Bowls Simpson was a start. Obama ignored it completely. Name one thing this guy has done besides spend $5trillion we don't have. Invent a health care system that we can never pay for. Just adding more to the $60trillion in unfunded liabilities. Hope and promises are not sound policy. Please, name one thing this guy has accomplished!
liberator100 writes:
What an unfortunate article. This paper has been in the bag for Obama for a long time. It must not be easy to be No. 2 in a small market. Romney was 100% correct in what he said. He stands by his words. Obama stinks as the Middle East burns. Foreign policy is a foreign word to this useless President.
ajm3s writes:
"I told you I was going to do it"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6uHR9...
August8 writes:
You are so right is there any reason a sane person would spend .50 cents on this rag?
Instead of picking apart this meaningless statement they should focus on providing American's with the real news on the Obama Record, beyond belief.
1Paradiselost writes:
So where should this paper get it's news source...FOX? Or should they get it from right wing nutjobs like Karl Rove or yourself?
You support a guy who tells our enemy how to kill Americans with a dirt bomb. Forget about Obama for now .. Tell us why you support a man who wants to kill Americans with a dirty bomb?
When are Republicans going to run candidates that DON'T look and act like 1970's game show hosts?
August8 writes:
If you like I will respond to your post but provide the specific information you are speaking about. I don't agree with your charatorizing these people that way. You must admit that left leaning folks love the name calling that's why there is little interest in your posts.
If the shoe fits...... you know the rest.
Sparky100 writes:
Not once in any Romney advertisement I have seen, does he say to the 49%ers, this ad is not for you. If some of those 49%ers do vote for Romney, I predict a landslide. Here are some past words of wisdom from the empty suit, the great Obama. So true, so true.
“The fact that we are here today to debate raising America’s debt limit is a sign of leadership failure. It is a sign that the U.S. government cannot pay its own bills. It is a sign that we now depend on ongoing financial assistance from foreign countries to finance our government’s reckless fiscal policies. Increasing America’s debt weakens us domestically and internationally. Leadership means that, ‘the buck stops here.’ Instead, Washington is shifting the burden of bad choices today onto the backs of our children and grandchildren. America has a debt problem and a failure of leadership. Americans deserve better.” – Senator Barack H. Obama, March 2006.
1Paradiselost writes:
August8
I believe the question is I my 2nd paragraph.
I'm starting to understand what Rick Santorum said, When he told a group of conservative Republicans at the Values Voter Summit on 9-17-2012, last weekend
"That smart people will never vote for Republicans".
liberator100 writes:
1Paradiselost:
"So where should this paper get it's news source...FOX? Or should they get it from right wing nutjobs like Karl Rove or yourself?"
You got that right. You must be a leftist nutjob. Your Kool Aide is waiting. A clueless and helpless arrogant man like Obama will always depend on a Kool Aide drinking nutjob like you. You must have lost more than paradise!
1Paradiselost writes:
Liberal100
Instead of telling us the reasons why Romney is the best person to be president, you say Obama is Clueless, Helpless & Arrogant.
Well we heard your three reason why you dislike the President. Please enlighten us on three adjectives describing Mr. Romney. Please don't use these, Etch A Sketch, Liar, or Romney 6.0.
Try to be positive about Romney without mentioning the president of The United States. I bet you can't do it!
Yesterday conservative Peggy Noonan (Ronald Reagan former speech writer) said yesterday... “This week I called it incompetent (Romney), but only because I was being polite,” she writes in a column today. “I really meant, ‘rolling calamity.’
Conservatives are fleeing the ship like the rats at sea.
Our president represents all Americans, yes, even including YOU!
Say what you want about Kool-aid. But dumb is just plain dumb. Common sense is not so common and as Ron White says "You can't fix stupid"
There's still HOPE? Yes with Obama!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fL6wbs...
KlausStoertebeker writes:
Liberator is a former KKK grand wizard.
Who would bear the law's delay
when he himself might his quietus make
with a bare bodkin.
He can not insult
GREAT PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA.
His guy is nuts.
It is crucial that Romney pick a running mate who will help him with the groups he's weak with: women, Hispanics, African Americans, Evangelical Christians -- and Republicans.
August8 writes:
Sparky, keep the faith my man not winning this election would be a defeat for America. I am with you my man/woman.
KlausStoertebeker writes:
GREAT PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA will win!
There is something indicative about his character because it seems like Mitt Romney was kind of a bully. This was not the only bullying thing he did. He also took poor kids' lunch money -- oh, I'm sorry, that's his present-day economic policy.
GREAT PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA will win!
Share your thoughts
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.